Duress to Murder and its Documentations in Imamieh Jurisprudence & law of Iran

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 ssistant Professor of Qaemshahr Branch, Qaemshahr, Iran

2 Sari Branch, Islamic Azad University, Sari Branch, Islamic Azad University, Sari, Iran

Abstract

Based on rules of Imamieh jurisprudence and Iranian criminal rights (including Article 151 of Islamic Penal Code ratified in 2013), one of the eliminating factors of criminal liability is duress. Duress includes “mental pressure imposed on a person through whom his free will and authority (consent) is waived at the time of committing that behavior”. The present paper discusses determining intentional murder judgment resulting from duress and its documentations in Iranian rights (Articles 375 to 380 of Islamic Penal Code ratified in 2013) and Imamieh jurisprudence. This study concluded that firstly, the failure in elimination of criminal liability from the person subject to reluctance in the status of duress to murder is based on the distinction without reference and principle of human being lives equality. Secondly, the basis of eliminating criminal liability from the person subject to reluctance to murder in the case of being minor or insane is the rule of stronger cause from the foreman. Thirdly, Imamieh jurists’ opinions concerning permission or prohibition of killing in terms of duress to murder are not the same; however, the most well-known idea of Imamieh Jurists and consequently, Islamic Penal Act (IPA) ratified in 2013 is principally based on prohibition of murder in the case of duress to killing. 

Keywords


. Alhor  Alameli, M. (1980). Vasaeloshie Ketabol Ghesas Va Aldiat (5th ed). Tehran: Maktab Islamiyeh Publication.
 
2. Anvari, H. (2007). Big culture of speech (4th ed). Tehran: Sokhan Publication.
 
3. Ardebili, M. (2014). Law of public penalty. Tehran: Mizan Publication.
 
4. Gheblei Khoiee,  K. (2001). Principles of jurisprudence (penalty section) (7th ed). Tehran: Samt Publication.
 
5. Goldozian, I. (2004). Law of public penalty of Iran (7th ed). Tehran: Tehran University Publication.
 
6. Helli, M. (2010). Sharayeol Islam (2nd ed). Tehran: Aladab Najafol Ashraf.
 
7. Jafari Langroudi, M. (1961). Law terminology (4th ed). Tehran: Ibn Sina Publication.
 
8. Khomeini, S. (1989). Ketabol Baye (5th ed). Tehran: Esmaeilian Publication.
 
9. Khomeini, S. (No date). Tahrirol Vasileh (2nd ed). Qom: Darolelm Publication.
 
10. Majlesi, M. (1981). Beharol Anvar, research of Seyed Ibrahim Mianji and Mohammad Bagher Behboudi (3rd ed). Beirut: Darol Ahya Torath.
 
11. Marashi, S. (1995). New views in penalty law of Islam (1st ed). Tehran: Mizan Publication.
 
12. Mir Mohammad, H. (2014). Law of special penalty (1): penalties against people. Tehran: Mizan Publication.
 
13. Moieen, M. (1984). Farsi dictionary (6th ed). Tehran: Amirkabir Publication.
 
14. Mousavi Khoei, S. (No date). Mabani Tokalemeh Menhaj (1st ed). Beirut: Daroulzahra.
 
15.  Safayee, S & Ghasemzadeh, S. (2002). Civil law (people and insolvents) (7th  ed). Tehran: Samt Publication.
 
16. Shahid, S. (2008). Alroze Albahih Fi Sharhe Almah Aldameshghieh. Tehran: Publication of Scientific and Cultural Complex of Majd.
                       
17. Shambiati,  H. (1998).  Law of special penalty (4th ed). Tehran: Vistar Publication.
 
18. Shams Nateri, M. (2013). Law of Islamic punishments in current legal order(1st ed). Tehran: Mizan Publication.
 
19. Shokri, R. &  Ghaderi, S. (2005).  Law of Islamic punishments in current legal order (4nd ed). Tehran: Mohajer Publication.
 
20. Tousi, S. (No date). Mabsout (3rd ed). Qom: Mortazavieh Maktabah Publication.